Task: Case "Experiences abroad"

Read the case study and in your learning journal note down what you think went wrong. Refer to your knowledge of interculturality, perception, experiences and expectations and be guided by questions about the encounter, the people involved and the feelings of the participants.

One of the more apparent challenges for me was living with my Indian colleagues. I had big problems adjusting to loud noises, pungent smells and the pretty much non-existent hygiene of some of them. I met four Indian colleagues during my time at the company. I lived with three of them under the same roof. Two of them had the habit of conducting early morning phone calls. One of them did not want to clean at all because apparently believed that it was beneath his dignity. After I had told him several times that he had to clean like everybody else and he finally accepted. But I realized that he only pretended to clean when it was his turn. On top of that, he did not clean the toilets at all. Apparently, they do not do that where he is from. On another occasion, one of the other guys from India who had adapted slightly to the European standards cleaned the kitchen floor with the same rag he used for the bathroom floor. When I confronted him and said that this is definitely not a hygienic move he replied that he always does it this way.

I was willing to accept their habits but most of the time they did not accept what was important to me or criticised ‘European habits’. For example, there was an occasion where the lab leader came over for a beer with Malu our lab technician. I was cooking some Spaghetti Bolognese. He opened the pot and laughed. “What kind of shitty food is that?”, he asked. I said: “Just try it. Maybe I can prove you wrong.” Then he just walked away. In situations where I wasn’t so sure whether my stomach would be capable of handling Indian food, I sometimes declined their offer. Immediately, you could see that they were disappointed and sometimes even angry at me for declining.

 

Having completed this task, click on the following link to view a possible answer.

Show / hide sample answer

The given situation describes an intercultural encounter between a European man (nationality is not specified in the case study) and his three Indian colleagues, all of them lived together. Problems they faced were mostly of household character because they had absolutely different understanding of housekeeping.

Early-in-the-morning phone calls, hygiene and cleaning issues – all of the mentioned were parts of their routine confrontations. On top of this the European felt criticized when he was trying to explain his neighbors the universal rules, he believed everyone should adhere to. The case study also describes a situation when the European offered a dish to his Indian neighbor who refused from it in a rude manner. Moreover, the European also felt sort of frustrated because he was trying to accept his neighbors’ ruler, while they were reluctant regarding his rules.

Feelings experienced by the both sides can be assumed to be the following: the European felt disregarded, criticized and disappointed, Indians were dominating in the situation and felt that his rules were not obligatory as they had no motivation to change their own habits because of the European neighbor.

I guess that they lacked good and comprehensive conversation and a compromise. For making living together more comfortable and easier they should have discussed some points instead of walking away. Clash of cultures could be avoided if both of the parties are ready for the dialogue.

I can assume that this piling tension between the sides also negatively changed the mutual perception. To be able to overcome the feeling of otherness could certainly help the participants of situation and give them some space for privacy.


Zuletzt geändert: Freitag, 9. Mai 2025, 15:46